Skip to main content
Recruitment & Retention

Some employers are recruiting workers they laid off for AI

Over half (52%) of workers in the US and UK have experienced or seen “AI rebounding” in the labor market.

• 3 min read

TOPICS: Recruitment & Retention / Talent Acquisition / Employer Branding

Companies that laid off workers to invest in AI might be second guessing their choices.

Over half (52%) of workers in the US and UK who were surveyed by talent insights company SHL have experienced or heard of someone who has experienced “AI rebounding,” when companies try to re-hire workers who were laid off amid costly AI rollouts because companies realized those roles still required a human touch.

“Instead of investing into the people that they already had, they rather went down the direction of letting them go,” Sujay Saha, an employee experience strategist and founder and CEO of consulting firm Cortico-X, told HR Brew. “Now, what they are doing…[is] getting a lot of the people who are trained or have the aptitude for AI to be hired back in their company.”

What’s going on? This year, companies including Microsoft, Oracle, and Amazon have slashed headcounts to spend more on AI. It’s a strategy many have used in recent years as AI tools have become more common in the workplace.

When companies are looking for an ROI, “replacing employees with AI is an easy win. It looks on paper like you’ve had productivity wins. ‘We’ve got rid of headcount. Aren’t we doing good?’” Lucy Beaumont, SHL’s global SVP of product, told HR Brew. “But not thinking it through, and then making mistakes, and then having to rehire them…I would like to think that people start getting much more intelligent around it and not making that mistake”

Even though the labor market has been relatively cool in recent months, the most recent JOLTS data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics showed that job turnover increased slightly in September. Laid-off workers might be feeling more optimistic, and not as quick (or desperate) to return to their previous employer.

Quick-to-read HR news & insights

From recruiting and retention to company culture and the latest in HR tech, HR Brew delivers up-to-date industry news and tips to help HR pros stay nimble in today’s fast-changing business environment.

By subscribing, you accept our Terms & Privacy Policy.

That seems to be the case among SHL survey respondents: 8% said they’d refuse to be re-hired after being replaced by AI. Those who said they’d consider accepting such an offer would only do so if they were guaranteed a pay bump (51%), job security (42%), or transparency about AI in their role (40%).

“What that is saying is, ‘We don’t trust you anymore. You’ve broken our trust, and so, we will come back, but how can we start rebuilding that [trust]? I want to understand: Have I got job security here, and I want to know exactly how AI is going to be used?’” Beaumont said.

How this impacts HR. People leaders should be aware of “the bigger costs” associated with re-hiring employees after layoffs, Beaumont said.

“The cost is damaged employee morale, damaged engagement, lower productivity. People will leave as soon as they get the opportunity,” she said. “The impact is much bigger than what that report finds, because it’s very difficult to build trust. Very easy to break it, really difficult to rebuild.”

Recruiters tasked with re-hiring employees should also look for those who are adaptable and willing to evolve alongside technology, Saha said. It’s a skill that employees will need to develop, and recruiters will need to source for, to stay competitive in the marketplace.

“It’s those Herculean times when a lot of things are changing, and employees just need to understand that…they need to really dress up and be ready for the change,” he said. “It’s not about lacking skillsets. It’s about the agility to go about changing it.”

About the author

Mikaela Cohen

Mikaela Cohen is a reporter for HR Brew covering workplace strategy.

From recruiting and retention to company culture and the latest in HR tech, HR Brew delivers up-to-date industry news and tips to help HR pros stay nimble in today’s fast-changing business environment.

By subscribing, you accept our Terms & Privacy Policy.