• 3 min read
Experts share how HR can improve the hiring experience for recruiters and candidates alike.
Getty Images
AI is increasingly finding its way into the hiring process, and it’s affecting HR pros’ confidence in their ability to assess candidates.
The majority (90%) of employers think they’ve rejected real candidates over seemingly fake or AI-generated applications, according to a new report from applicant tracking software company Greenhouse. And it’s no wonder why they’re so on guard: 73% of HR pros have come across “fabricated or misleading candidate information,” HR Brew reported earlier this year.
Hiring is in an “AI doom loop,” Ariana Moon, VP of people transformation at Greenhouse, told HR Brew. Candidates are using AI to create and submit applications, while recruiters are using it to sift through and detect fraud in applications. But the tech isn’t always improving the experience on either end, according to Moon.
AI is causing some problems. Many recruiters are overwhelmed by the amount of AI in the application process, Laura Mazzullo, founder and owner of East Side Staffing, told HR Brew. As applicants use it more, recruiters are using it more too, but not necessarily to their benefit, she said.
Instead of using AI defensively, to safeguard their hiring process, recruiters should be using it strategically, to improve the candidate experience, create hiring best practices for managers, or increase the efficiency and fairness of the application process, Mazzullo said.
“Recruiters are so bogged down going through these applications that they’re not freed up to elevate their role,” she said. “CEOs and founders…would love an internal recruiting team that’s really strategic, and guiding us, and advising us, but it seems like all they do all day is go through applications.”
More tech, more human touch. AI-powered hiring tools are not without their flaws, and research shows that pervasive use can lead to biased or discriminatory outcomes. As HR teams increasingly use these tools, Mazzullo said, they’ll need more humans to oversee them.
“A lot of people forget, you’re still dealing with two human beings on either end. You’re dealing with a candidate that has expectations for a certain experience, and you’re dealing with a hiring manager who’s very trepidatious about making a bad choice,” Mazzullo said. “So, you have both humans there looking to the recruiter for guidance.”
Recruiters should be transparent and explicit with candidates about how they’re using AI in the hiring processes (to craft job descriptions and interview questions, for example) and how candidates can use it, too (say, to prepare for interviews), Moon suggested.
“If you’re going to try to infuse trust back into a broken hiring process where there’s too much noise and people don’t know what’s real, then you have to start with transparency,” Moon said.