Experts in HR and board governance spoke with HR Brew about the factors that cause corporate boards to take notice of such CEO indiscretions, and to what degree CHROs are involved.
Getty Images
There are workplace affairs. And then there are workplace affairs that threaten the national security interests of your company and, in turn, the nation.
Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang recently engaged in the latter type of affair, an investigation by the New York Times found. He resigned as president and CEO of the semiconductor chip manufacturer on Nov. 12, after reporting revealed that he’d engaged in multiple personal affairs with employees and business associates, including a Nvidia customer suspected of being a Chinese spy and a woman who reported directly to him.
Experts in HR and board governance told HR Brew about the factors that cause corporate boards to take notice of such CEO indiscretions, and to what degree CHROs are involved in the disciplinary process moving forward.
When an HR violation turns into a board issue. Consensual affairs don’t automatically constitute a corporate governance failure, Andrew Jones, director of the Conference Board Governance and Sustainability Center, said. The situation changes, though, when the sharing of sensitive company information, or potentially misleading statements, is involved.
“Boards aren’t there to govern people’s marriages, but they absolutely have a responsibility…when personal conduct creates conflicts of interest, compromises the company.”
What’s more, when a board is made aware of a relationship between a CEO and an employee, there’s “most likely a very significant imbalance of power,” he said. “That can affect decisions about people’s careers and how they’re treated…other employees will then wonder sort of how that affected decisions being made.”
Companies with good governance typically have policies in their code of conduct that forbid CEOs from having relationships with direct reports, Ani Huang, president of policy and practice with the CHRO Association, said.
“There’s almost no way to mitigate the power differential when it comes to a very senior executive and somebody who’s not,” Ani Huang said.
In the case of Jensen Huang’s affairs, both potential conflicts of interest and power imbalances were at play. His affair with Alice Huang (no relation), a Nvidia customer who had been flagged by US intelligence for working as a Chinese spy, prompted concerns that the CEO had shared sensitive information about the company’s chip technology with a foreign competitor. After the news of Jensen Huang’s relationship with Alice Huang became public, news outlets reported that he also had relationships with Nvidia employees—including Kimberley Powell, Nvidia’s vice president of healthcare, who reports to him.
Nvidia’s own code of conduct states that employees should “avoid situations where our actions might create a conflict,” and lists “personal relationships” as a type of activity that may create a conflict of interest.
How involved is HR in a CEO investigation? Once a CEO has violated a company’s code of conduct, the board typically opens an investigation, and retains independent counsel to help conduct it, Ani Huang and Jones said.
While CHROs might be involved in fielding an initial complaint about a CEO that leads to such an investigation, they’re not likely to be involved with the investigation itself, due to concerns about appearing conflicted. “A lot of what the board is doing is really around maintaining the brand and the reputation of the company to say, ‘we’re taking this seriously and we’re an independent board…we’re going to be investigating this objectively,’” Ani Huang said.
(Nvidia’s board has launched an independent investigation into the allegations that Jensen Huang was a foreign intelligence target, assisted by an outside independent counsel, it said on Nov. 8.)
Once a board makes a decision about a CEO’s future, the CHRO may then be involved in the search for a successor, as well as explaining the decision to the company’s employees, Ani Huang said.
“Sometimes it may be that your employee base does not fully understand why—especially if it’s a very beloved executive—why the board has asked him or to leave,” Ani Huang said. Explaining that the company followed an objective third-party process, backed by evidence and independent counsel, may give employees “a little bit more transparency around why that decision was made.”
Even though CHROs aren’t typically involved directly in misconduct investigations like the one currently ongoing at Nvidia, scandals like these may prompt more companies to seek out board members with experience in HR, both sources said.
Though the share of former CHROs serving on public company boards remains small, the Conference Board has tracked an uptick in the share of independent directors reporting some kind of human capital expertise or background in recent years, Jones said. He added that he expected that trend to continue, as boards recognize “how valuable it is to have real deep human capital, human resource expertise on a board, not just for issues like this, but…to inform those discussions around culture and people management.”